What is wrong with Shelby in Steel Magnolias?
Steel Magnolias, a poignant drama that delves into the lives of a close-knit Louisiana family, showcases the struggles and triumphs of its characters. Among them, Shelby, portrayed by Julia Roberts, is a complex character whose actions and decisions leave viewers questioning what is truly wrong with her. This article aims to explore the various aspects of Shelby’s character and the underlying issues that contribute to her troubled nature.
Shelby’s initial portrayal in the film is that of a strong-willed and independent woman who is fiercely protective of her family. However, as the story unfolds, it becomes evident that Shelby’s actions are driven by a deep-seated insecurity and fear of abandonment. This fear is rooted in her difficult childhood, where she felt unloved and unwanted. As a result, Shelby becomes overbearing and controlling, trying to maintain control over her family’s lives to ensure they do not leave her behind.
One of the most significant issues with Shelby is her inability to let go of her past. She clings to her memories of her deceased mother, M’Lynn, and becomes obsessed with living out her mother’s dreams. This obsession leads her to make irrational decisions, such as pressuring her sister, Annelle, to have a baby, despite Annelle’s reservations. Shelby’s need to fulfill her mother’s wishes is so strong that she is willing to sacrifice her own happiness and well-being.
Another aspect of Shelby’s character that contributes to her problems is her codependent relationship with her husband, Lou. Shelby’s need for validation and approval from Lou is so intense that she becomes overly dependent on him. This dependence not only hinders her personal growth but also puts unnecessary pressure on their marriage. Shelby’s inability to stand on her own two feet is a reflection of her fear of being alone, which stems from her childhood experiences.
Furthermore, Shelby’s lack of self-awareness is a significant issue. She is unable to recognize the negative impact her actions have on her family and friends. Her constant interference in their lives leads to numerous conflicts and strained relationships. Shelby’s inability to see her flaws makes it difficult for her to seek help or change her behavior, which ultimately exacerbates her problems.
In conclusion, what is wrong with Shelby in Steel Magnolias is a combination of her deep-seated insecurities, fear of abandonment, codependent relationships, and lack of self-awareness. These issues contribute to her troubled nature and create a challenging dynamic within her family. While Shelby’s character is undeniably complex and relatable, her actions and decisions highlight the importance of self-reflection and personal growth. Steel Magnolias serves as a poignant reminder that while we may not be able to change our past, we can strive to overcome our fears and insecurities to lead a more fulfilling life.
